Plane emergency landings: Is your life jacket actually there? The truth about emergencies on planes

We’re sorry, this feature is currently unavailable. We’re working to restore it. Please try again later.

Advertisement

This was published 6 years ago

Plane emergency landings: Is your life jacket actually there? The truth about emergencies on planes

By Lizzie Porter
Updated
Loading

The trill is familiar: "Please listen to the following safety instructions..." But, particularly for frequent fliers, it's tempting not to tune in to the spiel that precedes every flight you will ever take.

Because flying is safe. According to figures from the Civil Aviation Authority, there is an average of one fatality for every 287 million passengers carried to or from British airports. In the past 40 years, survival rates in the event of a crash have increased: between 1971 and 1980, 48 per cent of passengers survived major incidents; that rose to 67 per cent in the decade 2001-2010. Last year, meanwhile, was the second safest year in aviation history – second only to 2013.

But since emergencies on planes do occur, as passengers on board a Thomas Cook aircraft in Hurghada discovered recently, cabin crew need to know how to handle them.

I attended a cabin crew training day at British Airways, and found out a thing or two about emergency situations on board. How do the staff get everyone off as quickly as possible? Should they even be directing people off the plane? And what happens if there's a fire?

Must you listen to the in-flight briefing?

There is no legal requirement for staff to make passengers listen to the in-flight safety announcements that take place at the beginning of every flight. Those who do not follow the instructions are responsible for their own fate. However, cabin crew can intervene if rowdy passengers are preventing others from listening.

If an emergency happens once mid-air, flight attendants are trained to calmly brief passengers with emergency procedures quickly.

If an emergency happens once mid-air, flight attendants are trained to calmly brief passengers with emergency procedures quickly.Credit: iStock

Is your life jacket actually there?

Advertisement

Staff learn emergency procedures inside-out, but as a passenger, do you check your life jacket is actually there? Although spares are available on board, it is not a routine BA cabin crew requirement to make sure each seat has its inflatable. If you want to be able to don it immediately in the case of an emergency, it's up to you to check it's stowed where it should be. And perhaps you should. George Hobica, airline expert and the founder of airfarewatchdog.com, once told the Huffington Post: "People take those life jackets, located under or between your seat, as souvenirs. It's a vile and punishable offense, and while some airlines do check each seat at the start of every day, a plane could make several trips in a day, during any one of which a passenger could steal a life vest. So, I learned, it's a good idea to check if the life jacket is indeed there."

And no, First Class passengers do not have their own parachutes.

The paradox of a 'planned' emergency

In terminology that perhaps sounds paradoxical, emergency landings can be "planned" or "unplanned". The former is when cabin crew know something bad is going to happen - you are going to have to make an emergency landing because of fire or engine failure, for example. The latter is when it just does, without warning - in the event of a terrorist attack, for instance.

Evacuation slides can kill

The emergency slides that you hope you never have to use can be "lethal weapons", according to James Austin, a British Airways training executive.

If members of cabin crew haven't made sure the door is in manual mode on landing, when they open it the slide will inflate in less than 10 seconds, and ground staff on the other side of the door "won't be there much longer", he adds.

Passengers that refuse to jump can expect a kick

In an emergency, if passengers are refusing to get out, staff need to be prepared to do anything to get them onto the slide, including pushing, kicking, and shouting. It is their responsibility to get people out, and there is no time to accommodate those with vertigo. At full pelt, 150 people can be off in 60 seconds. The crew would also check the flight deck before leaping for the slide themselves. Austin explains: "If the pilots got us down, it might be nice to make sure they are alive." For security reasons, staff are not allowed to reveal other emergency circumstances in which crew would be allowed onto the flight deck.

Landing on water - and building a raft

"Ditchings", as landings on water are sometimes known, should only be attempted if there is no other emergency landing option, like, for example, when fuel runs out or becomes contaminated.

To prepare the cabin for this type of evacuation, crew would need to instruct them to put on any available clothes, to improve chances of survival in the water, and secure loose items: once water enters the fuselage, any floating objects could impede evacuation. A reminder of the step we hear so often - "in the event of an emergency, do not inflate your lifejacket until outside the aircraft" - would be given.

The emergency slide then becomes a raft, and cabin crew would have to attempt to link the inflatables together, to make as large a mass as possible, so it is as visible as possible to search parties.

One ditching with fatal consequences was the emergency landing into the Bengawan Solo River, on the island of Java, by Garuda Indonesia Flight 421. The Boeing 737-300 experienced a dual engine failure on January 16, 2002. According to a report from the American National Transportation Safety Board, of the 60 occupants on board, one flight attendant was killed, 12 passengers received serious injuries, and 10 received minor injuries.

More recently, in 2009, a US Airways Airbus A320 was forced to ditch in the Hudson river after a flock of birds reportedly disabled both its engines. All 155 passengers and crew survived, earning the event the name of "Miracle on the Hudson".

But what if you don't want to get people off the plane? Austin continues: "If you start an evacuation too soon and someone gets sucked into an engine, that's not a good day, is it?" If the surrounding environment is too dangerous (on fire, stormy sea, a hostile terrain, say), it might be safer to stay in the plane.

The on-board fires you didn't even know about

Next up, fire. British Airways trainees have a full day on this, since they must be prepared to fight everything from a wisp of smoke escaping from an in-flight entertainment screen, to a potential explosion.

British Airways staff admit that "due to the associated electricals", plane seats can and do catch fire, although are cagey about how often this actually happens. If there was a serious combustion on board, however, the smoke could be so toxic that two, three or four breaths could kill; if all flammable materials on board ignited, temperatures would reach 1000C, and passengers would be unlikely to survive.

So would staff tell passengers if there was a fire on board? It would depend on size and location. If the fire was near them, in a door panel or in their seat, then obviously yes, but if it was in the galley, then they needn't be any the wiser…

British Airways cabin crew trainees learn the ropes in a smoke-filled chamber, and are taught how to don the gas masks staff are equipped with for fire-related emergencies.

In the London Telegraph's guide to surviving a plane crash, passengers are advised to count the number of rows from their seat to the nearest exit. After joining trainees in the smoke chamber, it was easy to see why - I was completely disorientated. The smoke was not toxic, but my eyes still stung as we clambered to the exit.

Why don't passengers get gas masks?

Putting on the staff gas mask, I felt like Darth Vader. Why don't passengers get them? I asked. Apparently they are reserved for those actually fighting the fire.

Statistics on how often there is a serious fire on a plane are hard to come by. A 2002 report from the CAA, however, suggested that, from the time of the first indication that there is a fire on board, crew have an average of 17 minutes to get a plane to the ground. Whether the fire is in the engine, the cabin, or is hidden (the most dangerous type of fire, as the delay in confirming its existence may allow it to spread), pilots are advised to land the plane as soon as possible.

The strange tale of the exploding coffee machine

Passengers might not have a gas mask in the event of a fire, but cabin crew come up against nastier on-board challenges when they are least well prepared – including exploding coffee machines.

The UK Flight Safety Committee, an association of professionals who seek to improve commercial aviation safety, reported a note from the Aviation Safety Reporting System, a Nasa body that reports safety incidents, which detailed an accident with an exploding coffee machine that took place in January 2014. The flight had to be diverted and a member of cabin crew received second degree burns to face and chest when they "lifted the handle of the coffee maker and hot coffee grounds exploded out onto [their] chest and face."

And what about pilot sickness?

Finally, what would happen if the pilot was taken ill during the flight, and couldn't land the plane? Late in 2013, Mike Gongol, an off-duty American Air Force pilot responded to the tannoy announcement: "'Are there any non-revenue pilots on board?", and landed United Airlines flight 1637 on its way from Des Moines, in Iowa, to Denver, in Colorado. The pilot had suffered a cardiac event and Mr Gongol was going to have to land the plane.

British Airways said that for long-haul flights they have up to four people able to fly the plane on board, so should a similar emergency occur, passengers shouldn't have to take to the flight deck.

Even if, heaven forbid, every pilot on board is incapacitated, all may not be lost. According to Bruno Gilissen, a pilot and contributor to the online forum Quora, landing a plane really isn't impossible. To read his idiot's guide, follow this link.

Safest years in aviation history | Deaths per total number of passengers flown

2013 - one per 11,501,886
2016 - one per 10,769,230
2015 - one per 6,144,642
2012 - one per 6,079,831
2011 - one per 5,318,702
2008 - one per 3,755,102
2004 - one per 3,478,821
2014 - one per 3,253,791
2009 - one per 2,960,526
2007 - one per 2,803,299

Sign up for the Traveller newsletter

The latest travel news, tips and inspiration delivered to your inbox. Sign up now.

Most viewed on Traveller

Loading